I still have vivid memories of discovering my first gay themed wrestling site on the internet - JPWA. Now I know that the site had it's share of problems and frankly the site is not technically 'gay' however, I can't escape how much of an influence it had on me at the time. The wrestler that stood out the most to me was Benjamin Quest, a cutie with an infectious smile.
Benjamin Quest (JPWA, Cyberfights.com)